论文标题
引用级联和主题相关性的演变
Citation Cascade and the Evolution of Topic Relevance
论文作者
论文摘要
作为科学定量研究的工具,引文分析长期以来一直强调直接引文关系,从而忽略了间接或高级引用。然而,一系列早期和最新研究表明,世代相传的间接和连续引文的存在。除了有关高级引用的文献外,我们介绍了引用级联的概念:一系列随后的引用事件的构成,由某个出版物发起。我们通过分析超过450,000篇文章和超过600万个引文关系来研究这种引用结构。我们表明,引用影响不仅存在于先前研究中记录的三代人,而且还存在更多世代。尽管如此,我们的实验结果表明,两到四代通常足以追踪作品的科学影响。我们还探索了特定的结构特性,例如深度,宽度,结构病毒性和大小,这些特性解释了单个引用级联的差异。最后,我们发现证据表明,激发跨性别领域(或间接相关的领域)作品的科学工作比仅接受域内识别以实现高影响更重要。我们的方法和发现可以作为科学评估和科学史建模的新工具。
Citation analysis, as a tool for quantitative studies of science, has long emphasized direct citation relations, leaving indirect or high order citations overlooked. However, a series of early and recent studies demonstrate the existence of indirect and continuous citation impact across generations. Adding to the literature on high order citations, we introduce the concept of a citation cascade: the constitution of a series of subsequent citing events initiated by a certain publication. We investigate this citation structure by analyzing more than 450,000 articles and over 6 million citation relations. We show that citation impact exists not only within the three generations documented in prior research, but also in much further generations. Still, our experimental results indicate that two to four generations are generally adequate to trace a work's scientific impact. We also explore specific structural properties such as depth, width, structural virality, and size, which account for differences among individual citation cascades. Finally, we find evidence that it is more important for a scientific work to inspire trans domain (or indirectly related domain) works than to receive only intra domain recognition in order to achieve high impact. Our methods and findings can serve as a new tool for scientific evaluation and the modeling of scientific history.