论文标题

决策支持,以最快的检测至关重要的共同阶段

Decision Support for the Quickest Detection of Critical COVID-19 Phases

论文作者

Braca, Paolo, Gaglione, Domenico, Marano, Stefano, Millefiori, Leonardo M., Willett, Peter, Pattipati, Krishna

论文摘要

在流行病的过程中,当局最具挑战性的任务之一是决定采取哪种限制性措施以及何时应执行这些措施。为了以完全理性的方式做出明智的决定,必须尽快确定以传染的指数增长为特征的关键政权的发作。提供严格的定量工具来检测这种发作,这代表了科学界的重要贡献,以主动支持政治决策者。在本文中,利用最快的检测理论,我们提出了COVID-19大流行进化的数学模型,并开发了决策工具,以快速检测从受控制度到关键方面的段落。提出了一个新的顺序测试 - 称为桅杆(均值不足的顺序测试) - 并在来自不同国家的公开可用的Covid-19感染数据上进行了证明。然后,对第二大流行浪潮进行了桅杆的性能,显示了平均决策延迟$δ$和风险$ r $之间的有效权衡,其中$ r $与声明需要采取不必要的限制性措施所需的时间成反比。理想情况下,决策机制应在给定风险水平的情况下尽快做出反应。我们发现,所有国家都在最快的检测方面具有相同的行为,特别是随着延迟的指数级别的风险量表,$ r \ sim \ exp {( - ωδ)} $,其中$ω$取决于特定国家。对于相当小的风险水平,例如,一万个可能性(即平均每27年一次无动力的对策实施),提议的算法检测到关键制度的开始,延迟了几天到三周,比指数增长更早。

During the course of an epidemic, one of the most challenging tasks for authorities is to decide what kind of restrictive measures to introduce and when these should be enforced. In order to take informed decisions in a fully rational manner, the onset of a critical regime, characterized by an exponential growth of the contagion, must be identified as quickly as possible. Providing rigorous quantitative tools to detect such an onset represents an important contribution from the scientific community to proactively support the political decision makers. In this paper, leveraging the quickest detection theory, we propose a mathematical model of the COVID-19 pandemic evolution and develop decision tools to rapidly detect the passage from a controlled regime to a critical one. A new sequential test -- referred to as MAST (mean-agnostic sequential test) -- is presented, and demonstrated on publicly available COVID-19 infection data from different countries. Then, the performance of MAST is investigated for the second pandemic wave, showing an effective trade-off between average decision delay $Δ$ and risk $R$, where $R$ is inversely proportional to the time required to declare the need to take unnecessary restrictive measures. Ideally, the decision mechanism should react as quick as possible for a given level of risk. We find that all the countries share the same behaviour in terms of quickest detection, specifically the risk scales exponentially with the delay, $R \sim \exp{(-ωΔ)}$, where $ω$ depends on the specific nation. For a reasonably small risk level, say, one possibility in ten thousand (i.e., unmotivated implementation of countermeasures every 27 years, on the average), the proposed algorithm detects the onset of the critical regime with delay between a few days to three weeks, much earlier than when the exponential growth becomes evident.

扫码加入交流群

加入微信交流群

微信交流群二维码

扫码加入学术交流群,获取更多资源