论文标题

亲属关系是一个网络跟踪社会技术,而不是进化现象

Kinship Is a Network Tracking Social Technology, Not an Evolutionary Phenomenon

论文作者

David-Barrett, Tamas

论文摘要

一方面,亲属关系是一种普遍的人类现象,倾向于与生物学相关性保持一致,这可能表明进化基础。另一方面,亲属关系在人类种群中具有显着的差异,这表明文化基础。此外,即使其基础是生物学的,亲属关系通常过于不精确,无法有效地跟踪遗传相关性,而包容性健身理论只会暗示只关注最近的亲戚,在大多数人类文化中并非如此。这些矛盾的论点的平行有效性导致了数十年来关于现象的定义和衡量的激烈争论。本文为亲属关系提供了一种新的方法。首先,该模型表明,可以产生亲属网络(a)我们物种与其他猿类共享的基本亲属连接的种类,但是(b)由网络驱动而不是直系亲属以外的生物学逻辑。其次,该模型表明,作为网络启发式作品的亲属关系仅在高生育社会中有效,并让位于基于人口过渡的基于相似性的友谊。结果解释了(i)为什么亲属标记是我们物种独有的,(ii)为什么亲属关系在人类文化中是普遍的,(iii)为什么亲属关系术语系统在各种文化之间变化,(iv)为什么语言亲戚分配不准确,以及(v)为什么当亲戚稀少时,亲戚在同性恋中替代亲属。该模型为有关人类亲属关系概念的社会和进化人类学之间的辩论提供了一个统一的框架。

On one hand, kinship is a universal human phenomenon that tends to align with biological relatedness, which might suggest evolutionary foundations. On the other hand, kinship has exceptional variation across the human populations, which points to cultural foundations. Furthermore, even if its foundation was biological, kinship is often too imprecise to track genetic relatedness efficiently, while inclusive fitness theory would suggest focusing only on the closest relatives, which is not the case in most human cultures. It was the parallel validity of these contradicting arguments that led to decades of fierce debate about the definition and measurement of the phenomenon. This paper offers a new approach to kinship. First, the model demonstrates that it is possible to generate kinship networks (a) derived from the kind of basic kin connections that our species shares with other apes, but (b) driven by network rather than biological logic beyond the immediate family. Second the model demonstrates that kinship as a network heuristic works efficiently only in high fertility societies, and gives way to similarity-based friendship with demographic transition. The results explain (i) why kinship labelling is unique to our species, (ii) why kinship is universal among human cultures, (iii) why kinship terminology systems are varied across cultures, (iv) why linguistic kin assignment is imprecise, and (v) why kinship is replaced by homophily when relatives are scarce. The model offers a unifying framework to the debate between social and evolutionary anthropology concerning the concept of human kinship.

扫码加入交流群

加入微信交流群

微信交流群二维码

扫码加入学术交流群,获取更多资源